#FFXIVHEALERSTRIKE

[BigBoom550]

The devs listening to threads like this are what ruined WoW.

Healing as my main role since Shadowbringers... there's a lot of jank around healers even in their own role.

Healers don't need to be DPS. But SGE and SCH spend half their time fighting over mitigation, AST has had its identity reshaped basically every expac, SCH's kit fights itself... WHM's basically the only one that more or less works, and even then WHM's kit has a little bit of counterintuitiveness to it.

There is, bluntly, an endemic problem with healer design. Their kits tend to fight itself, WAR can go without Healers for patch content, and you're both expected to do DPS but not given enough tools to make that aspect engaging in a lot of content. It stems from the overall issue of healer design itself having to be weird due to solo content.

I'm not on the strike myself, but I play Sage because the kit doesn't fight itself as much as the other classes. WHM's the next best in that regard, I feel, but man do I feel bad for SCH mains.

[Supersnow845]

Healing as my main role since Shadowbringers... there's a lot of jank around healers even in their own role.

Healers don't need to be DPS. But SGE and SCH spend half their time fighting over mitigation, AST has had its identity reshaped basically every expac, SCH's kit fights itself... WHM's basically the only one that more or less works, and even then WHM's kit has a little bit of counterintuitiveness to it.

There is, bluntly, an endemic problem with healer design. Their kits tend to fight itself, WAR can go without Healers for patch content, and you're both expected to do DPS but not given enough tools to make that aspect engaging in a lot of content. It stems from the overall issue of healer design itself having to be weird due to solo content.

I'm not on the strike myself, but I play Sage because the kit doesn't fight itself as much as the other classes. WHM's the next best in that regard, I feel, but man do I feel bad for SCH mains.

I play SCH specifically because I don’t wanted everything handed to me with no choice like SGE

that’s a feature not a bug

[CaptainLagbeard]

Thank you.

I don't think these problems are endemic to healers -- tanks and dps suffer from those, though nobody ever expects responsibility from a dps.

Having said that, I understand some of the gripes since I caught a glimpse of what AST and SMN (my former main) were when I purchased the game pre-ShB. And even then summoner worked very strangely indeed, and by ShB time it didn't feel like a proper summoner at all. It used to be about egi management, at least a little, and now it is about watching the pretty colors while doing kindergarten piano practice.

But then, I fail to name a class - bar maybe Pictomancer, Viper and Sage - that works differently. It's always rotation, and you move in those circles and you literally cannot make a meaningful choice anymore.

The base gameplay loop of doing your basic rotation is basically the same on every class... But other Jobs do have differences to each other when their CDs and mechanics get involved... Like Reaper you got listed, it has Blood Stalk and Enshroud. Those work very different from something like Monk's Perfect Balance and Blitz.

But for Healers, we get 1 attack, 1 DoT, and 1 or 2 attacks on CDs.

[Rolder50]

The devs listening to threads like this are what ruined WoW.

Interesting comparison considering that healers in WoW are 100x better then here.

[sharknado]

They did rather drastically change PLD in 6.3, for the worse in my opinion and they've buffed it just about every patch afterwards which says something... So they can do reworks mid-expansion.

That's a rotation of a job while here it would have to be a redefinition of all healers and no one even knows what the new definition would be. If they push for healers to be active at healing but not directly have a damage rotation on the boss for damage then it may turn out older content is broken and needs adjustments (like some ultimate and savage). If healers get FELL CLEAVE then the healing itself will be a punishment as the game would be balanced around the higher DPS output of healers (and old top content could also be broken as well) so we could end up with healers being like dancer or bard but with all healing moved to OGCs and limited in numbers so their wise usage actually matters. Maybe we could even delete Astro and make Machinist a medic?

And to make it even more complex - if they want to move dungeon design they now can't or they get current DT dungeons where if the healer doesn't know the mechanics or makes a mistake he dies and wipes the party unless the boss is low enough for the tank to finish it (it's fine to heal one DPS as WAR, but two is asking a bit too much... and I just wanted to level up my WAR...). But if healing wouldn't be a primary role and DPS jobs could adjust some of their secondary skills to have a rez, to have a basic cure then the dungeon is 1/3 instead of 1/1/2 and you can do more. And if you add an emergency tank cooldown as say - summoning a tonberry tank or white magic warrior statue then the dungeon is just 4 players and the content can be even wilder... but that turns the whole game upside down and won't happen

[Talianore]

Interesting comparison considering that healers in WoW are 100x better then here.

Seems they suffered a similar issue, but the devs are nerfing tank sustain over there

With the introduction of the Dragonflight talents system and season-over-season changes, tanks in World of Warcraft have become extremely durable relative to non-tank characters. Their active defenses can mitigate high percentages of incoming damage and they have strong self-healing. Today, in the hardest content in the game, many tanks can sustain themselves without much assistance from healers. In some cases, we’ve seen it become optimal to do group content without a healer at all.

But they are fixing it by reducing tank sustain, imagine that.

To address the above, we’re making reductions to tank durability and self-healing. This will allow us to smooth out the damage tanks and parties take while retaining the challenge of keeping them alive over time. We’ll take those changes into account in encounter tuning as well.

[Aword3213]

The devs listening to threads like this are what ruined WoW.

Sorry to burst your bubble, but WoW is still the most popular MMO on the market. It's more successful than FFXIV

Even Diablo IV has higher active player count than FFXIV.

[Lann_Gallowfield]

Both Ex trials cleared with no healer your strike didn't work. #RemoveHealerRole lets see some interesting solo style class design everyone heal themselves and get to blasting

[Isala]

Yup.

That's why a lot of things are boring - in gaming and beyond - : "always hide the differences between people (especially differences in capability), or one way or another you will create problems."

After years of teaching, I've lost faith to think otherwise...

My sister was a teacher. The stories she'd tell me about how much her class suffered in having to cater to the absolute worst students, that wouldn't try, and didn't care, were appalling. The amount of times she'd get screamed at by entitled parents, furious because their precious angel got the grades they deserved were too damned high, and her administration wouldn't do anything to stop it. Meanwhile, the truly gifted students were ignored, because you can't have someone excel TOO much. Not when Derps Mclazy won't bother to pay attention for even a single day in his life.

[Rein_eon_Osborne]

Both Ex trials cleared with no healer your strike didn't work. #RemoveHealerRole lets see some interesting solo style class design everyone heal themselves and get to blasting

Funny that you mentioned those no-healer trials when that was what some of the striker had been striving to do/hoping to see because the more it happens, the better.