Quote Originally Posted by aiqa View Post
A hugely overtuned job is the most used job. I am so surprised.
Warrior is a simple job that offers a good and reliable kit, it's often the first pick for tanks.
Not because it's broken, there's been situations where WAR has been on the lower end but still insanely popular.

Quote Originally Posted by aiqa View Post
We?
You can deny it if you want. It's proven you don't need a tank, dps or a healer to clear dungeons.
You can refer yourself to my analysis of damage distribution in dungeon.

Quote Originally Posted by aiqa View Post
The game enforces trinity in roulettes, so it's obviously intended. And something can be broken in specific content.
And possible is not the same as optimal. Generally people consider speed the metric to optimize dungeons. The runs I've seen with a full dps team were very far from optimal.
The game doesn't enforce trinity, even when queueing with random, it's an arbitraty rule to have the safest composition. There's always a healer in Guildhests yet they're completely useless in most of the guildhest.
The 100 fastest dungeon not including healers is a lie, you can find healers in top 100 of Deadwalk and Tender valley. Even then, you gain 1 to 2 minutes which is pointless unless you need to farm it hundreds of times, which isn't the case.
Speed alone doesn't define an optimal way to farm, if a DPS dies your run suddenly becomes suboptimal.

Quote Originally Posted by aiqa View Post
If your car can only move forward on completely flat roads, and struggles to a halt when there is a little mud on the road, I would very much call it broken.
That's a completely different situation, what's your point.

Quote Originally Posted by Ramiee View Post
Hell I unlike most people would be fine with WARs current life steal to be on a longer CD either 60-90 seconds but that amount of healing every 25 seconds is something I can't see as justifyable unless the tank loses something such as damage in using it.
You could put it on 180s CD healers would remain boring in dungeon.
The rest of the WAR kit is perfectly enough to maintain the WAR alive, do you want to nerf them as well and make WAR a joke in other content than dungeons?