Quote Originally Posted by Reynhart View Post
snip
Okay so question: have you done any of the current savages? Your statement

Worse, someone who manage every mechanic correctly, but lack some skills in his rotation or some stuff might do lower damage that a stronger/easier character in the hands of the players that fail every mechanic, and will be the one to be punished because he's "bad".
makes no sense in the context of most of the current endgame raids. If you flub a mechanic, if you're lucky, the only person whose dps is lowered is your own. If you're not you just either killed (and thus dropped dps for everyone you killed by 25%) party members. V3S in particular if you don't watch your mechanics you're going to annihilate your friends more than your enemy.

So where does this "person who does mechanics flawlessly but has bad dps versus person who screws up every mechanic but has godly dps" image come from? Because I can't think of many fights where flubbing mechanics doesn't negatively impact your dps.