Quote Originally Posted by Powercow View Post
You think 20% crit devalues crit by 20%.
If you want to be precise, then that is not what I think.

but I'll go one step beyond. This is now how it works. I showed, thanks to basic math (and yeah, it's that simple!) that going from no crit rating to a heavy emphasis on crit rating only devalues it by 6%.
Congratulations on, again, not answering the correct question / solving the correct problem.

Mathcraft fails when you use it for the wrong purpose.

You keep saying this, but you've never shown anything. You just keep making stuff up and trying to pass it off like it's true.
I've uploaded and linked my model 3 separate times. IDGAF if you believe me or not.

Anybody can punch numbers into a spreadsheet and come up with any conclusion they want;
I do it better than most. Actually I'm most pleased with the part where I used a quasi-recursive set of formulas to loop buff timing to close rotations so you don't have to do that manually. Combined with the automatic DOT clipping corrections.

the important part is if you put the numbers in correctly, which you clearly did not since you're getting wholly incorrect answers.
Based on your napkin analysis that isn't even coherent for stat/gear evaluation? Kbro.