Stormblood Scholar could be back in 8.0

[Sylvain]

I didn't bring this up this is already in the current design..aetherflow system for scholar which you consume aether to do healing or doing damage.. this is already in the design since ShB..

This is not the same.
The current design is OR, your design is TO

You need AF to heal OR to dps
You need poison stack TO heal

in fact this actually inforce healers to play the game as intended as developers says "healers must DPS" this is the current design even if you don't like it there is no contradictions..

Dude how can you be so hypocritical.
You complain that current SCH focuses too much on DPS, you want to reduce the amount of DPS skill and want healer to be able to 100% focus on healing.
You propose something that does litterally the opposite, I point it and you then say "well this design goes along what the dev want, us to dps, so I don't see the problem".

"the reason that we can't have healer without DPS spells is the game design.. I wish we can have it but we can't bro.. the game designed in a way that healer must do DPS.
and how to make Healer DPS interesting? to make it part of their kit."
Your words.
You wish for healer without DPS, to not have to choose

my idea is to actually in force healers to do what they suppose to do damage(which how developers intend healer to do) and healing with no point that you will choose DPS over healing.
What does the poison stack do? According to your tooltip, a DoT damage.
What does a healing spell/ability do? Heal + consumming a poison stack.
Do you do more damage with 5 poison stack than 4 poison stack?
yes : then you're back to the current system, damage or healing. You chose to heal at the expense of 1 poison stack until re-applied
no : Then what are the stack for? Just remove ED at this point and you reach your end game and SCH stops needing to dps OR heal.

.

double stack is a utility spell not a dps gain

Boss has 5 stack, receives x damage over the next server tick.
two scenarios unfold
use "double stack" : boss goes up to 10 stack, receives 2x damage.
do not use "double stack" : boss stays at 5 stack and thus receive x damage at the next server tick.
2x > x, therefor more damage (a dps gain)

Like for real? Doubling a DoT stack is not a dps upgrade? (unless you're idea is of a stackable poison dealing no damage)

at this point I really don't know weather you troll or you just don't understand FFXIV healer design.

Men you sure seems confident about your understanding and experience in the game, really curious about your achievement to speak with such a condescendant tone.