Quote Originally Posted by Physic View Post
no, not really. because one group forces a punishment upon the other.

it would be different if kicking a player cloned the instance, and put both groups at the top of the queue for replacements, but that is not the case.

considering on average we are talking a difference of a few minutes more for slow pulls, its basically pretty selfish.

basically the group of 3 is gambling to get their acceptable playstyle tank, but they make the tank pay the price if they lose the gamble. They knew theyd get a replacement easily.


if they spoke to the guy, and he said he would rather leave, that would be a different story.
i dont really think having to immediately requeue (especially since in this case the person requeueing likely wont have to wait even two minutes) is much of a punishment. if they got a 30 minute penalty then i may see the punishment angle. as it stands there is no price paid.

i play an mmo to have fun, not to put up with others when i dont have to. if one of us feels so strongly about something, then one of us needs to leave; if not them, then me. (e.g. if i feel a few minutes longer with slow pulls is unacceptablely unfun and theres no visible reasoning or compromise i'll try to kick. kick doesnt go through? i'll leave instead then)