Yoshi-P on Character Growth

[Remedi]

No core of any game should be a repeat of the same thing over and over and over. Having some similar elements is fine...but keeping things exactly the same and stale will never be fun. You can keep the foundation..of course, absolutely. But what is built upon it should be innovative and creative. Not the same thing with a new skin..

What I meant is that if you don't like an RPG you shouldn't keep playing one and whine that it should be an RTS, also I don't think that your statement is necessarily true, some games are still very popular despite beign a carbon copy of themselves and other gets panned because they get outside of their comfort zone too much, the last 3-4 FF are a proof of this. Personally also I find that very few things that are coming from the community are innovative at all since most of the time ppl are asking to make this game like FF11

[Reynhart]

What I meant is that if you don't like an RPG you shouldn't keep playing one and whine that it should be an RTS, also I don't think that your statement is necessarily true, some games are still very popular despite beign a carbon copy of themselves and other gets panned because they get outside of their comfort zone too much, the last 3-4 FF are a proof of this.

You might want to refrain of the overstatements a bit, don't you think ?

For you, asking for changes is akin to wanting to play an RTS ? Yeah, sure...Oh, and by the way, did you...hmmm...played Lords Of Verminion ? Tell me how great it fits in the J-RPG genre...

As for the recent FF, despite what your personal opinion is, FF XIII was a huge success. It's the 4th game when it come to sales. So yes, stepping out of their comfort zone was a good idea.

[Remedi]

You might want to refrain of the overstatements a bit, don't you think ?

For you, asking for changes is akin to wanting to play an RTS ? Yeah, sure...Oh, and by the way, did you...hmmm...played Lords Of Verminion ? Tell me how great it fits in the J-RPG genre...

As for the recent FF, despite what your personal opinion is, FF XIII was a huge success. It's the 4th game when it come to sales. So yes, stepping out of their comfort zone was a good idea.

I expressed myself wrongly, I think this games needs some changes yes, like better dungeons, more bosses on raid, make hunts beign a bit more interactive like FFXII but some I don't agree that we need an overhaul of the system again
that's what I meant with the genre thing and probably I shouldn't have used the term whine so if I offended you I'm sorry.
Also I like FFXIII, no actually I like all FF, ask me my favorite I won't be able to answer you, that said I can see that a chunk of the fanbase is criticizing the newer FF for beign too outside of the formula. If you want my personal opinion I would say that FF made it's fortune by beign something different each time so I would say they are wrong, yet I can see their reasons