The Ninja Superthread

[Arkenne]

better fit on MNK

Not gonna say they wouldn't work on either MNK or DRG but I really like the tricky ways of the ROG and NIN, so, I would rather see those on a NIN.

A reason as of why Positionals sound so interesting for me is ironically because the current rotation, as Silent has already reminded us way too many times, is quite the tight one.

So I think Positionals could be used in order to evolve NIN's rotation and add even more Weaponskills aside from the current combos of AE, DE, SF and Mu. Hence, some sort of hybrid gameplay between MNK and DRG.

Well, personal opinion on this xP

[Allyrion]

Not gonna say they wouldn't work on either MNK or DRG but I really like the tricky ways of the ROG and NIN, so, I would rather see those on a NIN.

A reason as of why Positionals sound so interesting for me is ironically because the current rotation, as Silent has already reminded us way too many times, is quite the tight one.

So I think Positionals could be used in order to evolve NIN's rotation and add even more Weaponskills aside from the current combos of AE, DE, SF and Mu. Hence, some sort of hybrid gameplay between MNK and DRG.

Well, personal opinion on this xP

It's not that I disagree, but that's a big decision.
It turns NIN from getting some positionals to be more in-line with other melee, to positionals being a core mechanic to work around.
And with more unique positionals than rest.

I, personally, might not mind it that much, but it doesn't seem like a natural evolution of the Job.
I can see the tricky part of it. Just I think it might be a jump from where the class is right now.
Might be better later on.