So what exactly IS the issue with Warrior?

[Hanabira]

I never forgot that, I mentioned it specifically. Paladin Cooldowns are the only thing that separate us. Period. Hallowed Ground is once every 5 minutes. It's 10 seconds per fight, MAYBE 20 (Not sure how long Twintania lasts) of immortality. Yes it's great. We all know. Your not opening anyone's eyes to that ability. Like we are all saying, it's Paladin Cooldowns. End of story.

Yes you said that, but you crunched very theoretical numbers like they would be on equal footing if one decided not to properly defend themselves, when 1 is clearly taking 0 damage and healers are generating 0 hate. has any pld ever kited phase 5 without using any cooldowns? then your numbers would be valid. Not to mention your numbers dont include block. Sure both war and pld can parry, so you can cancel those out on paper, but blocking makes the numbers skew greatly

Basically, what your numbers say is. if we have both pld and war, and one of them does everything they can to survive, and the other one isnt wearing a shield and does nothing to defend themselves, they are practically the same.

also, a storms eye is not healing for 250 unless you are getting a crit with a dmg buff. in most cases it heals for about 150