Counter to Elitism

[Reynhart]

The drops in dungeons like that are luck items. Even if you run the dungeon, you're not guaranteed to get what you want. And really, why should you be? True, you did difficult content.

Indeed you're not guaranteed to get exactly what you want. But getting Dark Matter nine times out of ten after beating the crap out of a Primal is maybe too far in the wrong direction.
You see, if dungeons and primals always dropped one good item for the party, I'd think that would be fair. You had to win the loot to get your item, but in a static PT, you know you'd get a reward at least for the 8th run.

I don't understand how "winning over a dice roll" is "satysfying". Cause basically it's how the drops work.

exactly like the Rajas ring, bullshit hard to get, but so worth it even at 99 its still the best ring, and you can use it at 30 it was so worth the mind blowing hardness of CoP.

It's actually totally different from the Rajas ring. Rajas/Tamas/Sattva were GUARANTEED if you finish CoP. Does that make them less deserved or less satysfying ?
When you saw someone with one of theses rings, you probably tought "Wow, this guy finished CoP, good job". When you saw someone with a HDL gear, you think "Wow...lucky guy"