Quote Originally Posted by Terhix View Post
Yes, and it has lead to the most lenient DPS check in a Savage tier in recent history.

The problem isn't that Bloodwhetting is just stronger than other tank oGCDs in aoe situations, the problem is that it's so absurdly stronger that you can't even bring other tanks to the same level without breaking balance elsewhere unless you give all tanks multi-target scaling. As of today the only other tank that has multi-target scaling is DRK with Abyssal Drain (which is 5.2% HPS of Bloodwhetting) and Living Dead (which has healing capped at 100% HP). It's fine if Warrior is the strongest dungeon tank, someone has to be, but it shouldn't be wild to ask for its abilities to exist within the same order of magintude as the other tanks.
It's also the first tier which consistently also has a more lenient DPS check than other tiers in the expansion to get people ready for what's to come. We also have some pretty strong jobs in the lineup and the balance isn't so terrible right now where tanks are 10% apart from each other in DPS. Good job not looking at other factors though.

Oh no normal dungeon content or the very rare adds in other content, the horror. Meanwhile it's quite handy in EX2 especially during congalines where everything hits pretty hard, and also helps the healers not have to snapshot a benediction when I'm invulning both TB"s so I don't die to the coming auto, or EX1 with most things going on in general. PLD is pretty fine, it does have a tough time staying up without Holy Sheltron though for my liking, GNB can do pretty nasty stuff in bosses with HOC but it's also the gas gas high dps tank and if anything I'd rather Superbolide give the invuln first then push HP to 1 instead of the other way around, that was a real fun moment to see during a Temple of the Fist run due to a bad tick which just should not happen, and DRK really could use more self sustain, they used to have a good amount back in SB. Granted it took DA spam to achieve it but there's ways to fix it without hurting WAR.

If Bloodwhetting was such a problem it would've been changed and Bloodbath would also be changed. Except it didn't. Try another avenue, it gets sad to see after awhile.