Quote Originally Posted by EaraGrace View Post
Oh yes I’m very aware of the arbitrary limit you placed and how even that doesn’t prove your point.



You have no coherent definition of death then if that’s the case. How are Emet or the rest of the Ascians any more alive than Minfilia who literally says she’s like an Ascian in SHB? How is Ardbert not alive in some form when he literally speaks to us? We’re we initially dead when we were sent back in time to Elpis? After all we were pretty close to Ardberts state until Emet gave us some aether. How would you describe a death then?




And now the motte and bailey. I want this to be clearly spelled out how you shifted the goals. We went from



To



But by all means continue to claim I’m derailing.




Then I guess killing Elidibus in 5.3 wasn’t a big deal! He already was dead after all!
You're free to continue to believe what stretched definition of death you want to believe. Considering even Yoshi P himself stated that there hadnt been death on the ally side for quite some time at that point and this was between 5,3 and 5.4...im inclined to believe him over an amateur lore enthusiast personally but by all means youre entitled to your opinion.