So you're telling me..

[Maverick_Haas]

Is it a strawman? you're the one here saying with a straight face that reaper is fine because it's all about playstyles and if you want to pretend to be a ninja like in your animes it's fine even if it's severely underperforming
so yeah I fully expect your full list of changes to be just a tiny slap on the wrist instead of the proper full array of nerfs it deserves

...Does it require some tuning? Yes

So with all this in mind, yes RPR does have a bit of tuning to do, but it shouldn't be regarded as a utility job and nerfed to the ground...

...I do think RPR needs some slight tuning...

Need I go on? Not to be toxic but please read. I don't misrepresent or strawman you. I read everything you have posted and I understand your issues with the job, and thus I have attempted to argue in good faith.

Adding this since it's relevant with your quote here.

Of course balancing is important, so that every job and even every configuration is viable within reason. My main concern here is that people are asking for nerfs such that RPR would be the gimp version of DRG, and iirc someone even suggested it to be less than NIN, all for a 3% damage raid wide that's more for enabling more damage during burst windows.