Quote Originally Posted by Khimer View Post
No, they are not fine, every warrior that knows what they're doing will tell you that guaranteed DCrit is awful. Not only it screws with crit scaling, but also with melding for omnitanks. On top of that most raid buffs are completely useless for warrior and that's just stupid. 4.2 fixed a lot of problems for WAR but it was done in a really bad way. They should just change IR to dmg buff, or make IR only crit and bring back 60s berserk, while also giving warrior minor potency buffs. Like there's no reason for FC to not be 600 pot like Bloodspiller, or its combo finishers 400 pot. That way le new war mains™ can have their unga bunga spam™ and warrior won't be AS awful.
Yeah, I think I can confidently say that I "know what I'm doing" more than the overwhelming vast majority of Warrior players out there, and I think that IR and IC are completely fine as is. Could some things potentially be tweaked to be better? Absolutely so. But at the end of the day the only real major "issue" that WAR currently has is just a slightly lower than desired DPS profile, something that could very easily be fixed with minor potency tweaks. Barring that the job doesn't really need anything else.