Tank Stances, Traited

[Reynhart]

Terrible idea. Part of the fun of tanking is switching between the two stances

Not for every player, and like Shao32 said, we're not "stance dancing" anyway.

The problem with your idea Reynhart, is that to make damage consistently dangerous to a tank that is getting -50% damage, you are making everything absolutely DEADLY to everyone else who would get near an attack from that same boss.

Other jobs are not supposed to take hits directly from the boss, so I'd say it's not really relevant (And frankly, direct hits are already deadly). AoEs are rarely dangerous by themselves for tanks, even out of tank stance, because the gap in HP means that if the tank dies, everybody else will.