Dragoons... how do you feel post 4.0?

[Khel]

No changes in 4.01, they going to evaluate dps on omega but the translated discussion on reddit basically says dragoons are where there are because of their utility they "greatly" increase party's dps. No mention of the issues with eye mechanics.

[Frowny]

No changes in 4.01, they going to evaluate dps on omega but the translated discussion on reddit basically says dragoons are where there are because of their utility they "greatly" increase party's dps. No mention of the issues with eye mechanics.

They have a VERY loose definition of "greatly". BL, while great, is inherently random given the nature of crits and the fact it is on a 3min cooldown. In current EX runs, you usually get 2 good uses out of it so 40s of a 15% increase. Not horrible, but not life changing either. Hungry Eyes (or Dragon Sight) is a 2min cooldown I think? And 10% for us/5% for our tether buddy IF they're right up on us for like 10s. Given a baseline of 3k DPS, that's only an extra 3000/1500 damage. It is something (2/1 free GCDs roughly), but not make-or-break. Disembowel is a nice buff, but is only 5% and applies to 3 classes, but you can only count on having one of them (the DRG obviously to apply it).

Let us look at NIN now. Trick Attack is a flat 10% buff for everyone for 10s on a 1min cooldown; that adds far more than Hungry Eyes, can theoretically be used more often and doesn't require a BFF. They also have that slash debuff (or did in 3.0, not sure if they still do but WAR does I believe as does SAM) which KEPT its 10% and applies to 5 classes (tanks, SAM and NIN) and you will always have 2 of them in content where said buff is relevant. They also still have Smokescreen and Shadewalker which are still great buffs for tanks or a DPS going wild.

In short, I see where the devs are coming from but disagree just from glancing at NIN's toolkit (someone who knows NIN better than me feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, this is from skimming job actions and from being around a few so I have little experience). This isn't even touching on the problem of LoTD either.

[Khel]

They have a VERY loose definition of "greatly". BL, while great, is inherently random given the nature of crits and the fact it is on a 3min cooldown. In current EX runs, you usually get 2 good uses out of it; that is hardly a huge difference.

Hungry Eyes (or Dragon Sight) is a 2min cooldown I think? And 10% for us/5% for our tether buddy IF they're right up on us for like 10s. Given a baseline of 3k DPS, that's only an extra 3000/1500 damage. It is something, but not make-or-break.

Gonna edit to add more.

I've seen greatly and hugely depending on the translation.