Samurai Discussion

[Shortie]

Damage is way too good atm, it's going to be nerfed hard, like really really hard unless other classes catch up with high-end gear. Also, the class is extremely easy to play "right" (no resources decay, spenders don't break combos, buff and debuff with very long durations, no RNG procs, short CDs) so it's a good option for new players. The only trap is the back step, it's going to kill a lot of people (like Dragoon jumps).

So far I like it and it's going to be my DPS main, just don't get used to his damage.

If you look at the numbers and buffs to skill speed, SAM wont be as good as Monk or DRG.. but it will be close.
Dont confuse big numbers with DPS. I personally think monks are going to be ridiculous. They are designed for power creep.

I dont think SAM is going to be adjusted. Yes they have big numbers, but the numbers come off a 1.8 second cast time and by using Kenki to buff ability. So I think its pretty balanced.

[Driavna]

...

I don't agree with this, an "annoying" resource to manage is energy from WoW's Rogue's or Rage, samurais have full control over his Kenki generation (also, no decay). For raids sure, save kenki to use with party buff or to destroy adds but that's about it. Also I don't understand why others tanks are losing aggro vs SAMs, must be gear disparity because with my PLD no problem at all.

...

I don't now, chakra generation is RNG, one fight you can be lucky and demolish the guy another GL HF (like crafting! :P). Is one of the thing I would love to be changed in the future (I really dislike RNG procs).

[EdwinLi]

I don't agree with this, an "annoying" resource to manage is energy from WoW's Rogue's or Rage, samurais have full control over his Kenki generation (also, no decay). For raids sure, save kenki to use with party buff or to destroy adds but that's about it. Also I don't understand why others tanks are losing aggro vs SAMs, must be gear disparity because with my PLD no problem at all.

As I said SAM has very good Burst Damage if Kenki built up to 100 and spent in one go. Probably the highest in the game currently but during the down time while building Kenki energy their damage is average and much more easy to manage aggro during these moments for tanks.

It will most likely adjust over time as people over level on higher ilevel gears to be must easy to manage.

[Shortie]

Chakra generation isnt RNG.
Bootshine guarantees one per rotation, and then you have an RNG chance (but a very high RNG chance).
Then brotherhood produces massive Chakra for 15 seconds of burst with +30% damage

[Driavna]

As I said SAM has very good Burst Damage if Kenki built up to 100 and spent in one go. Probably the highest in the game currently but during the down time while building Kenki energy their damage is average and much more easy to manage aggro during these moments for tanks.

It will most likely adjust over time as people over level on higher ilevel gears to be must easy to manage.

But is still an easy resource to manage, no RNG or constant generation. You lliterally can use a spender before hit the next skill that grant kenki to avoid capping it, keep doing that if you need to save if you don't spend as soon as you have enough to use mobility skills if needed.

Is one of the things I like about the class compare to monks.

Chakra generation isnt RNG.
Bootshine guarantees one per rotation, and then you have an RNG chance (but a very high RNG chance).
Then brotherhood produces massive Chakra for 15 seconds of burst with +30% damage

I'm not sure about Bootshine, from job guide only grant a critical strike and deep meditation give a 50% from weapon skills critical strikes, yes is high enough but still RNG, Brotherhood is 30% per weapon skills used. Another problem is "wasted" chakra during brotherhood, a few extra "doors" would be lovely.

[Shortie]

Not sure about wasted chakra since forbidden chakra is off the global cooldown, or can use purification

[Niyuka]

SAM and MNK both identical gear, same Ilvl weapons, lvl 66. SAM outperforms the MNK by an insane margin. Its not even the same league. And SAM is easier to play, more comfortable when soloing and less dependant on knowing the boss abilities and breaks.

[Shortie]

SAM and MNK both identical gear, same Ilvl weapons, lvl 66. SAM outperforms the MNK by an insane margin. Its not even the same league. And SAM is easier to play, more comfortable when soloing and less dependant on knowing the boss abilities and breaks.

level 66 means nothing.

To explan further, samurai from 66 to 70 doesnt gain as much. They gain a hard hitting level 70 ability, but its on a long cooldown and cost 50 kenki (which is a ton).
Monks gain Riddle of fire (which is huge) and Brotherhood (which is huge since it has a pretty decent uptime).

And Sam wont gear quite as well as other classes.

I just want to remind people that SE is pretty good about class balancing. You may laugh, but its a ton better than most MMO's. And they have a good mind to keep most classes relevant.
THis same doomsday thought process happened at heavensward, and everyone was pretty happy in the end.

AKA... play what is fun.

[KingMeteo]

I got lucky and built my skills into a triangle like the 3 tsubas are in, helps a lot.

123 is my 10% damage combo
45 is where I put the other two pices for the other 3-combo
I put the slashing debuff skill above my 1

So that way it just so happened that each skill granting sen is in roughly the same place it appears in the tsuba triangle.

That's what I did with my Cross hot bar aswell,

[Selova]

level 66 means nothing.

To explan further, samurai from 66 to 70 doesnt gain as much. They gain a hard hitting level 70 ability, but its on a long cooldown and cost 50 kenki (which is a ton).
Monks gain Riddle of fire (which is huge) and Brotherhood (which is huge since it has a pretty decent uptime).

And Sam wont gear quite as well as other classes.

I just want to remind people that SE is pretty good about class balancing. You may laugh, but its a ton better than most MMO's. And they have a good mind to keep most classes relevant.
THis same doomsday thought process happened at heavensward, and everyone was pretty happy in the end.

AKA... play what is fun.

I'm pretty sure it's a bit early to making assumptions on how SAM is with gears caling. No one even knows what our stat priority is yet. While Samurai does have the biggest hits out of all the melee their damage has a consistent flow outside of their charged attacks, not on the level of monks and ninja's in terms of speed but it's up there. Another thing to note, is you're never going to be building up a full kenki gauge in pve unless you want your damage to suffer severely because it means you aren't using any Ogcd's or Kaiten's to empower your attacks, which is a massive dps loss, they def have the highest burst potential with Meikyo Shisui, but they pack quite a bit of consistent damage if you're playing it right. These are just my current thoughts as currently from what i've played at 64.