I never claimed that, merely that the potential differences between tanks probably isn't going to be the make or break, which I think is the gist of this thread, the picking of diff classes and how pld dps is lower than other classes.

My example was a conservative estimate that shows how little potential tank dps variance matters. Not as a realistic you need this much dps.

People have certainly cleared a1s with a pld...it is pretty weird to for example, have a raid team ask their tank to go drk or war because they can't make a dps check. That is not the onus of the tank.