Quote Originally Posted by subteraneanbird View Post
Your math doesn't factor the (equivalent to) 10% potency boost from Cleric Stance.

Your final numbers are 74.8 p/s and 62.9 p/s respectively, which further swings it into Stone 2's favor exclusively for single targets.
Ahhhh cool! thanks for the addition

Quote Originally Posted by ariaandkia View Post
You forgot one factor.

Stun. Stone 2 doesn't stun. Stone 1 slows. Holy Stuns. Aero and Aero 2 apply DoTs.
No, I didn't forget. This is concerning single target dps and neither stun nor slow will matter because you have at least 3 other people beating on the target and negating the effect. Besides, how do you quantify a factor like that? We were crunching numbers based on a controlled scenario, status effects don't fit in.