Quote Originally Posted by Kalandros View Post
Thats just theoretical BiS for Twintania.
You don't need that much Accuracy for anything else.
So you take off the earring and use the allagan one instead. You take off the acc belt/ring and use a better one instead. I mean, I can math out sub-448 acc sets, but this is BiS for 448. The whole point was to disprove the long help (by many, not all) idea that CRT > DET for purposes of determining what is best, when it isn't that simple.

Quote Originally Posted by WorldFree View Post
Maybe I'm missing something here but, once you have the Weapon Damage Formula, isn't the only thing that matters the crit modified base damage?

With Bio as an example I get 116.418 for the "old" BiS and 116.245 for the "new" BiS set.

Using Fester as an example I get 873.142 and 871.843 for "old" and "new".

Not sure why that doesn't correlate to the Stat weights and Total INT calculations. But old > new on per cast basis

EDIT: Also, What about Maim and Mend I at Level 20 which is a 10% boost to base action damage
Damage per cast is not the whole picture, you need to factor in spell speed, which contributes to overall weight.

Maim and Mend I does not stack with Main and Mend II.