Quote Originally Posted by BigBoom550 View Post
She was explicitly targeted as a child because she was a young, female hrothgar? She was referred to as a 'rare, female child' by her biological father and targeted as such, she's consistently referred to as 'she' through the story, her biological father is also a Hrothgar, nobody ever provides any indication she was ever anything different. I think on one or two occasions she even refers to herself as female.

I genuinely have no idea what your position is here, because if your response to me making the clearly stupid argument, based on her own explicit statements, to prove how absolutely brain-dead a take it is... is to try and argue about the gender identity of a fictional cat I don't even know where to start with you. I hope you are trolling, and if not, may God have mercy on your soul.

Like, this is one of those cases we have extensive and explicit data on her history; she was given up by her father, clearly young enough she doesn't remember him at all. She's said as much. So unless your argument is a bunch of grown adults in a rural village got a hold of an extremely rare potion and shoved it down a random child's throat...
Quote Originally Posted by Vensaval View Post
What are you fishing for with this obvious bad faith argument? Genuinely curious.


holy moly, are you guys okay?