Quote Originally Posted by W00by View Post
Also, when did I insinuate that Caster is never hard ever? I just found those two mechanics easier. I'll be the first to say that BLM PoVs of the icicle mechanic in Valigarmanda make my hair start falling out even though that mechanic is braindead for my role. I just think those two mechanics are easier on caster than melee. Acting like I called all caster players knuckleheads when I am one myself is ridiculous, dude.

I don't have experience with BLM at 100, true, but I did play BLM for E5-E11 in Shadowbringers, so it's not like I have no idea how the class works. And while I haven't unlocked Picto, my best friend is a Picto main and we talk about it all the time, so I know he finds Arcadion 2 and 3 pretty approachable on that job, though I can only take his word for it.
See? You keep changing topics. "I raided as this and this 5 years ago", "Valigarmanda"etc. etc. Are we talking about Arcadion (and specifically those two mechanics) or not? I didn't insinuate that casters are never hard and I also didn't accuse you of it, either. Please, quote my exact words where I supposedly accuse of that, I'll wait.

You think those two mechanics are easier on RDM, not casters. Two entirely different concepts. You really don't see the difference?

Also, ShB was two expansions ago, BLM could be considered a different job now (sadly).

Anyway, you just keep contradicting yourself. Your initial point is (i'll summarise): X and Y mechanics are tricky on melee because it's hard to land positionals and you have to get creative with your tools. They are easier on casters (= actually RDM).

Then, you backpedal and say that yes, they are harder on casters if you want to play optimally... Exactly like positionals. Yet, you only make it a big deal when talking about melee.