Quote Originally Posted by Shurrikhan View Post
Your only sentence that followed what I quoted was on Cleric Stance. See the [HB] block.
Okay, why spoiler that though? Especially when you acknowledge the problem I pointed out with the idea? Like, what you did was specifically:

[Maybe we could do this...]
No! Absolutely not, there are flaws!
<Spoilers>
[...but there are flaws]
then let's discuss them
</Spoilers>

...just saying, the formatting is a little bit weird. Makes it come across like I'm the idiot for not realizing it unless you choose to "read more", whereas you had the bright idea to point out it's flawed. When in reality, no, I pointed it out, you're just being redundant and adding shady formatting. But you do you.

And no? I wrote a fair bit before getting into Cleric Stance. Heck, the Cleric Stance bit was separated by a quote to someone else. It had nothing to do with this. Basically I don't understand what you mean by "Your only sentence that followed what I quoted was on Cleric Stance" because... no it was not? It was a whopping paragraph, and the talk about Cleric came way later in another section on the post.

Quote Originally Posted by Shurrikhan View Post
Except, enmity combos would then replace one convenient oGCD with 2-3 additional GCD keys of otherwise zero purpose. And the thing is, you don't even need an action by which to replace tank stance. You need only buff Provoke to, say, apply an aura (hidden or otherwise) that increases enmity taken from the afflicter, or to have the tank enmity bonus be positionally dependent (only, say, 5x bonus from the rear, 7x from flank, and the 10x from the front).

You don't need to replace unnecessary action A with unnecessary action B, let alone C and D atop it.
I mean, at the end of the day, it's still going to be a buff. But if it's applied to Provoke, then at least that gives it a bit more to the pulling as well. Good shout, honestly.
But it wasn't just one GCD, it was two on some tanks. They replaced two GCDs with it.

Quote Originally Posted by Shurrikhan View Post
Don't make it specific to one's combo(s); else, one will no longer be able to gather with Flood, ranged attacks, etc. Just apply it to tanks across the board. There's no point in forcing the raid to delay their damage; there's no need to arbitrarily restrict the enmity aura buff to just a few tank actions.
Yeah but won't that also end up causing that "DRK, you do more than I do, both in APM and in damage, you pull" scenarios?