Materia: the new Armory System

[Coglin]

I get what you are saying but I don't know about that.
In no way am I obligated to offer an alternative if I am unhappy with any particular feature of FFXIV.

By no means did I say you were obligated. What I did say is was that you have no business complaining if they make a change based on this discussion, and you are even less happy. Basically be carefull what you ask for. Posters asked for a great deal of things to change, just to complain afterwords because he change suited them less the the original system.

You mention what constructive criicism means, yet you offer no consructive criicism. What most posters are doing in my opinion is just complaining. My point is, I see no reason to change the current system as it is, because it is better then what anyone else has suggested in my opinion.

tl;dr Offering an alternative isn't a prerequisite for discussing a feature you are unhappy with

I agree. Although in my opinion it is a prerequisite of defining the difference between the pissing and moaning some posters do, and actual constructive criticism.

That being said, do you have a point related to the topc? so far you few post on this thread have only been to complain about me asking a poster or posters for suggestion, a random movie comment based on a pic another poster displayed to ask for constructive feedback, another you comment about how a poster made a comment an hour before you, another post discussing the reply to your post about the "hour before" comment. One post was slightly topic related. thats 4/5 post to include your most recent, that are begining to look like trolling, but I will give you the benifit of the doubt. So, other then complaining about my take on asking posters for there ideas to better the situation versus just complaining about it. Do you have something constructive to add?

By you and "the rest of us" do you mean you and the people in your head?

No, the people in my head, do not play FFXIV, and one of them is threatening to kill 2 of the others, because he despises the color yellow. Do the people in your head tell you to troll post and having nothing topic related to say?

[BruceyBruceyBangBang]

No, the people in my head, do not play FFXIV, and one of them is threatening to kill 2 of the others, because he despises the color yellow. Do the people in your head tell you to troll post and having nothing topic related to say?

The reason I bring this up is because you often talk about this legendary group of people who support what you're saying, but they are never around.

The materia system is a cock block for future gear that is made u/u and takes out the need for long term goals in gear. If and when using just double melds you can hit your AA and WS DMG modifier caps... you have a problem.