I'll throw in my two cents:

For anyone who is struggling with MP on a scholar: You are doing it wrong.
For anyone who is bored with scholar and thinks it has nothing to do and it's boring: You're doing it wrong and obviously not utilizing all of your faeries abilities.

SO many times as a tank main I was AFRAID every single time I had a scholar in my group. I was constantly low on HP having to heal myself (Paladin)
I was having to use CD's when I shouldn't have had to use them just to keep from dying.
I feared for my pixel life on trash pulls (NOT pulling multiple groups at the same time. Just one trash pack.)

There's nothing wrong with scholar other than maybe its cast time needs to be reduced for broil and the damage needs to be increased both on it and the dot. I'd like to see another dot be given back to them or an instant cast damage ability with a short CD to weave inbetween broils and energy drain.

If you're having trouble healing on a scholar or keeping MP: I still stand by my statement, you are SORELY doing it wrong.