PLDs: You have Clemency for a reason.

[Yorumi]

Also, given I haven't run through the game as a PLD, how much would it hurt them if Clemancy was removed? For both their Job quests and Story Fights? And speaking of removed, a lot of people argue against it's use so what's the point in having it, but at the same time, what do you guys think would be a good replacement?

The spell is fine as it is really. Pld's already have too many skills anyway. PLds are supposed to have healing magic so it's good thematically. It's good for solo stuff and fine as an emergency skill from time to time. Mainly what people here are trying to get others to understand is that you shouldn't expect a non-healer to heal. Lets put it another way if we're letting the healer off the hook for failing to heal properly then we sure as heck can't blame the pld or rdm for not healing. Personally for me I just don't encounter healer that fail to keep me alive. Maybe it's because I do a good job tanking but if that's the case then we're basically looking at a combination of a bad healer with a bad tank and really what do we expect at that point?