I'll be totally honest reading through all this stuff, if you're not going to use it and it's not going to bother your gameplay experience why complain about it so adamantly?

Reminds me of the argument Jim Sterling used when people complained about Dark Souls having an easy mode. It was legit "Is this going to affect YOUR gameplay experience if other people have the option to use it? No? Then there's no actual reason for you to complain."

Except this argument is even more ridiculous since this is just giving people the option to replay the old content to experience the reward of the story. That in itself should be all you need, instead of leveling a new character through the beginning just to experience the same content you've already completed on your main. The same frustration of being level locked out of completing a MSQ related dungeon or not being a high enough level to complete a quest.

I know people are upset that it doesn't give any EXP (gil for obvious reasons) but let's be honest if you were going to level that job anyway through normal means the EXP you get from NG+ wouldn't be enough to progress far and you would still be level locked out of completing content anyway just plowing through the MSQ.