I thought Yoshi wants healer to focus on healing only..

[Kazrah]

"Get gud" doesn't work here when a bunch of DPS can't even reach the DPS needed for E4S if we don't factor in healer damage. AS in the classes just aren't strong enough to get passed the enrage timer.

If you want to beat the Savage enrage timers currently, either healers need to DPS, AND be good at it - or DPS all need to be BLM/DRG/Monk

It's also content intended to last at least five or six months. It's the fault of the players for trying to rush it with minimal gear, where healer damage becomes less of an option and more of a competitive edge.

Also, it's a human balance psychology things. Imagine if you live with 7 other peoples who hold each others equal, and technically only 4 of you have to work to get enough food for all 8. Do you think the group gonna last long if the other 4 just adopt a mindset of "well, if the other 4 works hard enough there is enough food for all of us, so I don't have to work for food" ? Saying "healer DPS shouldn't be necessary for clear" is the same-thing, it maybe, it maybe not, but the point is equal contribution.

This is a faulty comparison because it assumes that those four other people are doing exactly nothing when they could be doing other things that provide some other benefit to the group like doing things around the house. It's like saying that every single in hunter-gatherer societies has to hunt or else the group fails, which has never been the case except for cases in which hunters aren't able to perform their role effectively.

What about the healer who has to heal non-stop because the tank doesn't know what a cooldown is? Does that make them bad because they don't have any breathing room to do damage? You're basically saying that they are bad given your arguments as well as those requiring healers to do damage.