Consolidated Scholar 4.0 Feedback Thread

[Amaret]

Please stop posting and saying Scholar is strong in 4.0 when it got literally nothing but nerfs and is a fraction of what it was. Those saying they love Scholar at seventy are oblivious. So I compiled a list of facts of the state of Scholar right now and possible fixes. Don't reply to this and complain about one specific point I made. Just read it and become aware of Scholar's state.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1...it?usp=sharing

Not even 70 and not able to understand how strong chain strategem is.
This game isnt all about Dungeons & AoE Dmg. (But yea i admit non existent AoE makes dungeons boring)


Scholar is fine for raids and pretty much still the go to. Mana-Management is by far no problem.
Shadowflare is awesome how it is, especially for fights where the bosses disappear/need to be moved very often.(Its even stronger if you count in that you can broil 2 times instead of wasting gcd to cast shadowflare)
Embrace scale way differently than our normal heals. Embrace is still strong, and its free compared to the hots from ast/whm.
Adlo -> since MP isn't an issue... why reverting it? It should be used for tbs and hard hitting aoe (spread) not as just a better heal than physic.

This doc is just a pile of bullshit... its just a "mimimi make my class op plx" of someone who doesn't knew how to play Scholar befor Stormblood anyway.