Lore Book Revelations

[Belhi]

It seems very unlikely. For starters all the relic weapons are as the name implies, relics. Antiques, old. The Gae Bolg Estinein uses was likely made more recently.

Plus a lot of the relics seemed to had been mass produced in their heydey anyway like the Stardust Rods.

The Lore book, that calls Estinien's weapon Gae Bolg, seems to describe it as a holy relic. It would seem strange to have two relics with the same name and the same appearance. That would just be confusing.

It feels wrong, but until I find a place that the book is wrong in a different assumption, I have to accept it as an extraordinary heavy weight on the scales of probability... bummed, though I am.

I get why people are such big fans of Gaius but I don't see why people feel him actually being dead is wrong. Infact it's very believable. The guy would probably be 60 by now. Let him go guys.... He has had his run.