Block first timers from Party Finder!

[Ashkendor]

This is too discriminatory, especially the part about blacklisting people who make mistakes. People need to learn the fight somehow, and they aren't often run in DF or PF. Add an option that allows people who know the fight to completely avoid ever playing with new players and that's how it will end up being used. That's not that good for the game at all.

This is such a weak argument though, and I'm tired of seeing people fall back on this as an excuse. People that want to learn content can easily make their own parties for it if they don't see one in PF. Pretty much any content in the game, if you put up a PF for learning people will join either to learn or to help out. As far as blacklisting, I don't blacklist people that make mistakes unless they refuse to learn from them. I do blacklist liars that sneak into farms to waste seven peoples' time.

[Sapphic]

This is such a weak argument though, and I'm tired of seeing people fall back on this as an excuse.

Problem is, many that do this do not want to learn, they don't have the patience, they selfishly join with the intent of letting everyone else kill it for them.

How do people even make the link that it would ever be implemented in DF? Not only does it go against one of the main reasons DF roulette are there, but no other options from PF have made it to DF. Yay for fearmongering.

Digging for any excuse, no matter how outlandish, to try and counter the idea. Aka, they have no real response.

Personally I wouldn't be surprised if those objecting to this idea are the ones who do exactly what this idea would stop. Otherwise there is no reason to be against it.