Quote Originally Posted by Anastacy View Post
You mention "both sets", but there's actually 2 additional (DPS and tank), neither of which the Reddit-OP makes a fair attempt to analyze along with healer comms. And it is an assumption that healers deserve commendations because none of the analysis takes into account that maybe the groups the Reddit-OP didn't get any comms had a good freakin' tank that everyone thought deserved them.
That's exactly why anecdotal evidence or even small sample sets aren't good, but that sort of thing should average out over time. Biggest risk of that, I think, is the 2.5/Heavensward overlap, where the job dynamics changed so much the average number of good/bad tanks/dps may have also changed.