NINJA and ROGUE confirmed

[LoLo]

This is what I was saying above. They were very specific about Rogues not being thieves. Yes, they were very clear that rogues originated as thieves, but they also went to great lengths and said several times that they are not thieves.

When they said this so specifically any arguments like "if it plays like a thief it must be a thief" is just plain wrong. They said, very very specifically that rogues were not thieves.

A person in here to wants people to pretend they are a Thief even though the game tell everyone that it isn't a Thief but a Ninja. Sounds like mental gymnastics.

[Tiggy]

The person you replied to wants people to pretend they are a Thief even thought the game tell everyone that it isn't a Thief but a Ninja. Sounds like mental gymnastics.

It is mental gymnastics and it's ridiculous. I don't know how anyone can try to act like they are a thief at all. Yoshi couldn't have been clearer when he said they were not a thief.

[Nero]

The person you replied to wants people to pretend they are a Thief even though the game tell everyone that it isn't a Thief but a Ninja. Sounds like mental gymnastics.

That reply was directed at me and no, i don't. No clue where you get that from?! Or did you mean the first Reply towards Reynhart?

[LoLo]

That reply was directed at me and no, i don't. No clue where you get that from?! Or did you mean the first Reply towards Reynhart?

I was not meaning to direct that at you. I was just replying to Tiggy about another poster who actually said to pretend that you are a Thief because Ninja plays like Thief so just pretend to be a Thief and be happy.
Quoted below:

So let's say SE didn't name it "rogue"....and they named it Thief

If it feels like a thief, plays like a thief, has the traditional skills of a thief, then is a thief even if they name it burglar or robber...what's the difference? the name?
Then you care more for the name than the playstyle? They could throw you a thief healer and would be happy because is a "thief"?

When it gets to 30 and becomes a NIN..it will still have the thief playstyle...PLD still plays like GLD, DGN still plays like LCN, WHM still plays like CNJ....but then again the problem is the name? feels like a thief, plays like a thief, has thief traditional skills....but is named NIN and has 5 new skills?

After reading that I blocked their posts because I find them to just be a troll and the person that posted twice right after them is blocked as well because he was obsessed with replying to everything I post on the forums. I guess he loves talking to a wall because I can't see anything he saids lol.

(I edited the post to reflect that)