what i meant OP was it would seem wrong to take a pet class and have it change into a one shot job. I do agree with you if carby was replaced by more specialized pets people would use the latter. Im just concerned that the pet job ive been waitin the better part of a year is going to be relegated to just a class.

I personally am not a fan of carbuncle, i am a diehard ffxi lolpup. I wanted a pet job. Another way to interperet things is that summoner will still have carby, but gain the one shot spells and abilities to be used simultaneously while having him out. Having an ifrit move which creates a single crack under mobs or a garuda move to push back mobs doesnt seem op to me while still having carby out as long as its balanced properly.