What about an Eureka-like instanced pvp zone?

[Ath192]

Well I appreciate the additional information, that was indeed how Templar played at release and for a few years later, but considerable changes were made to the retail version over the years.

However, I don't see how that has anything to do with the homogenization in FFXIV, the player segments are very different, the job design with the ability to have multiple alts on one character is different, there are no skill trees here (stigmas), the whole core game vision is different.

Just saying that I appreciate classes being different even if they are not super optimal at every scenario. And right now the XIV PvP classes have distinct identities, so I wouldn't want them to get rebalanced and reworked to a point where they all feel the same just so any job can 1v1 in PVP well. I apologize if I didn't make that connection in the argument well.