Is there a disconnect between logic, reason, and FFXIV in your head?
=Player is inexperienced and bad=
=Player is less then a week old=
=Player was PL'd till 50=
=Player never had to play his class since someone got him heaps of EXP while he sat there playing Pokemon Red=
=BUT HE ISN'T BAD BECAUSE HE WAS PL'D! HE JUST DIDN'T WANT TO LEARN HARD ENOUGH!=
Saying that people should just magically learn how to play their job at cap when all they have left to fiddle with is End Game is like saying we should just gives cars to every 13 year old on their birthday.
"If he REALLY wants to be good he'll learn how to drive. He doesn't need some time to learn what the rules of the road are. How to properly place his feet. To judge distance and speed. Growing up is boring and he has a party to get to next week and he HAVE to be 16! He can't wait besides growing up is boring and it doesn't really teach you anything you can't learn at the end anyways."
Sure they'll learn but not before a great deal of damage has been done and in the end even if they DO figure it out they would have a better grasp if they began with fundamentals. Not to mention it would separate the good from the bad at least partly. A bad but determined player can cap out but more likely then not he'll stall at some point because PT's keep kicking him for being incompetent.