Quote Originally Posted by Issachar View Post
Rampage, Bloobath, and crit gear would like to have a word with you.
I took that into account, but thats not as reliable as cure or the other heal skills a PLD has. When it comes to self-healing, i'd rather it not come down to luck and the amount of dmg you happen to do. It is awesome when it works but as far as self-sufficiency goes a WAR has almost none, except for the exception you just noted.

I want to see a really good PLD and a really good WAR to make comparisons. It sounds like most of these comparisons are based on bad PLDs. PLD sounds like it has a much higher learning curve than WAR, so its more likely to produce lackluster results through personal experience.