Results -9 to 0 of 199

Threaded View

  1. #10
    Player
    Reinha's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2015
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    4,069
    Character
    Reinha Sorrowmoon
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Reaper Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Gaethan_Tessula View Post
    That's a rather silly bias to presume I would have. But no, my actual reasons are:

    1. BLU's current core identity is being able to granularly adjust its kit and role between instances (and, to a much lesser degree, in-instance). Developing a fixed kit for DF directly contradicts that core-identity. The devs would have to settle for picking one of BLU's sub-identities defined by the three extreme corners of its role selection: flute-burst, oGCD, and weakness-targeting DPS; ARR WHM, including Stoneskin II, but with more damage buttons; and a tank that uses actively cast mitigations, along with abilities that "reflect" damage back at the target (Chel' Gate, Veil of the Whorl, Cold Fog, etc.). Probably the DPS one exclusively since that's what BLU would queue as, unless they actually find a way for BLU to actually count as a healer or tank in terms of mechanics.

    I somehow think that BLU having to play the "diet coke" version of itself to use DF would continue to cause displeasure in the playerbase. Furthermore, locked-kits in DF would have a knockon of making it harder to balance BLU for current content; e.g., if the devs balance around their DF BLU, then PF BLU could be too strong. This would be especially problematic on JP servers, where DF is actually used for harder content.

    2. Making the two distinct, and the DF set likely suboptimal, creates a perverse incentive for players to not use Duty Finder. I've already seen some people complain that BLU as is made it harder to participate in the moogle-tome events as other classes, since so many went to BLU-burn parties in Party Finder. Permanently instituting this problem via having unequal DF and PF BLU as full jobs seems like something SE would want to avoid, as Duty Finder is the primary means by which new players progress through the game.
    Your reasons didn't explain why players who like using the DF shouldn't be allowed to use it as BLU.

    1. If you don't like being forced in the caster role as BLU, you can still use the PF. As for it causing "displeasure", those angry people can also just use the PF. This just sounds like a lame excuse to deny us what we are requesting. Or bias, as you put it. It has nothing to do with balance because a DF spell kit only requires 24-36 spells and BLU already has that many normal, unimpressive spells. The rest can be as imbalanced as they are since wouldn't be a part of the DF kit.

    2. If you find the DF set suboptimal, don't use it. The people complaining about BLUs only using PF during moogle events seem like a good reason to let BLUs pick DF if they want and keep those queues active. I mean... banning BLUs from DF is a bad incentive for them to use DF.
    (5)
    Last edited by Reinha; 02-13-2022 at 07:31 PM.
    Graphics
    MSQ
    Viper