You have types A, B, and C. Of those, only A interacts in a way that may be problematic with context X. Is X at fault, or A?
The argument was literally just that it could be either one. It is not necessarily X, as you and Alzinor have insisted.
________________
But, sure, let's back this up a ways, to where the point in contention becomes very obvious.
Even in ShB, you could no-heal and no-dps a majority of content-forms. You would not no-tank them.
Despite tanks clearly therefore being the more designed-in essential role, following ShB, Healer rDPS was decreased from ~64% of a DPS's to ~56%, while (Non-DRK) Tanks not only saw their free self-healing increased from as low as nil to a minimum of 4278 (and maximum of 12440 potency, even in single-target) per minute, their rDPS increased from ~56% of a DPS's to 64%.
Such will, very obviously, cause a shift in relative power in Tanks' favor (over both Healers and DPS), one that time had already proven is far from necessary -- seeing as any period in which tanks have ever become even briefly non-essential has meant immediate redress even while hardly an eye ever bats at Healers being made nonessential.
I say this as someone who plays Tank far more than Healers and prefers tanking to healing: We did not need the degree of power increase that was given to us in EW.
We needed more activity and agency, as arguably every role needed and still needs, but the increase to overall capacity was excessive. It would still be excessive even if there were commensurate added damage funneled into us; such would merely mean that the content would further solidify that imbalance.
Balance within roles is the first place we look to for job diversity, but when balance between roles fails, the whole game starts getting a bit wonky. We haven't yet hit any huge threshold or point of no return but we are certainly leaning that way, which is why we have both the reason and ability to do anything about it.



Reply With Quote







