What would the consumption reward be like?

And yeah, Vengeance has always been a weird outlier, especially since the rest of Warriors kit was standardized. I'd prefer others get their own benefits of similar value than remove that bonus, but since Shadow ringers it's been hard to point at any compensatory weakness in WAR's kit that'd warrant, let alone notably synergize with, Vengeance's reflect damage.

(At least back in Stormblood we had stuff like Blood Price and Oath Gauge from blocks.)