Final Fantasy XIV and a Culture of Enabling

[linayar]

Hard disagree a single troll should not have hold over an entire group.

The only thing this would do is make trolls more rampant and make people less likely to queue roulettes without a full premade.

That assumes that "trolls" are only/always on the side of the minority. This equalizes the playing field regardless of the size of the party you queue with.

Tbh if they had a vote system like this I probably would just do full premade groups and most likely no longer help friends with pops and stuff if it is a duo. Granted for the most part now we mostly run in house groups anyways either through our discord, ls, or FC.

Though I will say your system would put an end to so called vote kick abuse. Though I personally do not see how not wanting to play with someone is abuse and making it harder for people to remove those they do not wish to play with. Though I get the intent of your system.

My proposal does not stop people from deciding who to play with, just prevents "tyranny of the majority" by equalizing the votes. It assumes that you will side with your friends, so your vote might as well be one.

Not wanting to play with someone is not necessarily abuse, but it still makes them have to redo a duty if they get kicked. So if you really don't want to play with someone and there is no majority, it's more fair to just vote abandon than kicking the minority. This is within the context that "differences in playstyle" is a valid reason to separate and vote kick someone.