Imagine using the words “MCH” and “overpowered” in the same sentence....I’m kind of shocked right now. It is clear that you don’t really understand the current state of balance when it comes to the game.

As the physical ranged currently stand, all are alarmingly weak. None are overpowered. If they didn’t bring the 1% party buff to a group, BRD and MCH would for sure be benched, and DNC would only be invited to parties to Dance Partner the SAM or BLM. That is the current state of the role. Within said role, DNC reigns supreme because of its utility. MCH doesn’t do enough in terms of personal damage to really set it aside from DNC, and BRD’s lack of utility has hurt the job in more ways than just lore. It has fallen from the most popular DPS role to one of the least popular (at least in terms of Savage clears for it). But even non-raiders are complaining about the current design of it. And it has very little to do with BRD feeling “sluggish”, and everything to do with it being a BRD in name only.

And why would you give BRD ammunition? If any job were to get ammo, it should be MCH. That was actually part of the original design of the job. MCH’s base combo used to be RNG procs. You mitigated said RNG but losing ammunition into your weapon to guarantee that your next combo action proc’d. However, having your base combo be 50% RNG has its own design flaws, so they moved away from that system.