Everything wrong with 5.3 AST sleeve draw [Translated JP duplicate thread]

[hiz]

So I get that you have some high performance marks, and you're proud of it, but... Take care that you don't lose sight of the rest of the mountain when you reach its peak. If your ideas are as self-apparent as you make them out to be, then you wouldn't have needed to make this thread. Using GCD heals and getting some use out of Ladies doesn't necessarily mean you're bad at your job or that your group's at fault for making you use them- could just be that you're in prog still. Prog's an important part of the AST experience too, no?

I was always talking about optimization and optimized scenarios, which in my opinion prog does not fall into. This person was trying to act like he had an idea talking about optimization in a disrespectful manner, so I just told him I won't be fooled. Prog is a totally different story, and sure, Lady could have been of value there given the randomness of player performance inherent in prog, or PF, or any other given sub-optimal environment. My opinions remain unchanged on GCD heals and Lady on optimized scenarios; if you were treating Lady with utility in optimal situations, you were not optimizing this job well.


Edit: It is true that I do have very clear concrete ideas on this job that I have built from my gameplay and my own theorycrafting, which of course are subject to change... but not through failed roleplay attempts. Feel free to prove me wrong with math. The (observable) player skill of a poster is irrelevant to how I react, it is more whether the conversations are respectful or not. As for why I made this thread, I made it to shed light on opinions of a playerbase that are usually silent in places like this, as I (maybe mistakenly) believed there could be some value in doing so.