A popular MMO reviewer gave FFXIV Shadowbringers the thumbs down o.o

[CazzT]

nice dodge, but im still waiting to hear where i was wrong?

What are you talking about dodging?

How are you wrong? Well, since you asked.... Someone with that many 70s is more than qualified to criticize and speak on the flaws of the game. They clearly have enough time invested to have seen enough of the game. So your own attempt at deplatforming someone backfires.

And it doesn't matter how many 70s they have anyway. Most art and movie critics cannot create the things they critique. You weren't addressing the argument, you were attacking the person making the argument.

[Abriael]

What are you talking about dodging?

How are you wrong? Well, since you asked.... Someone with that many 70s is more than qualified to criticize and speak on the flaws of the game. They clearly have enough time invested to have seen enough of the game. So your own attempt at deplatforming someone backfires.

And it doesn't matter how many 70s they have anyway. Most art and movie critics cannot create the things they critique. You weren't addressing the argument, you were attacking the person making the argument.

Most art and movie critics are able to critique art and movies without going out of their way to disrespect the artists and directors as much as humanly possible.

No matter how many 70's you have. If you're unable to understand this basic concept, and this particular YouTuber obviously is not, then you have no business being a critic.

Which is the point, because this is no critique. It's called a "rant," and even as a rant, it's a poor one.

[Nobuyuki_Sanada]

What are you talking about dodging?

How are you wrong? Well, since you asked.... Someone with that many 70s is more than qualified to criticize and speak on the flaws of the game. They clearly have enough time invested to have seen enough of the game. So your own attempt at deplatforming someone backfires.

And it doesn't matter how many 70s they have anyway. Most art and movie critics cannot create the things they critique. You weren't addressing the argument, you were attacking the person making the argument.

You are incorrect in your assumption of my meaning. The post was defending the maker of a video claiming the leveling and the game was shit. I simply pointed out that it is odd someone has put soo much voluntary time into a game they didn't like. Even so much as to create numerous characters on such a bad game. I was pointing out a flaw with their position not their character. I have posted numerous times on the flaws in Lazy Peon's video if you would like to reference those and give a position the discourse is welcome.

[CazzT]

You are incorrect in your assumption of my meaning. The post was defending the maker of a video claiming the leveling and the game was shit. I simply pointed out that it is odd someone has put soo much voluntary time into a game they didn't like. Even so much as to create numerous characters on such a bad game. I was pointing out a flaw with their position not their character. I have posted numerous times on the flaws in Lazy Peon's video if you would like to reference those and give a position the discourse is welcome.

Nothing about what you just said can even be implied from what I originally quoted from you. It's most certainly not what you said.

[Nobuyuki_Sanada]

Nothing about what you just said can even be implied from what I originally quoted from you. It's most certainly not what you said.

That might not be what you understood but that is what I meant plain and simple. If your interpretation was different I don't know what to tell you. I explained myself and that's where I'm going to leave it.