Tank entitlement vs group entitlement

[Feidam]

Then the person performing at a sub-chocobo level is harassing the party, because obviously no person at that level is that incompetent.

I still don't comprehend why you're so dead-set against the group being the authority here.

Because as we have seen players behind a monitor will be vicious and petty if they think they can get away it. Also, one can look at real life and see that Majority Rule is often used to negative effect. We have guidelines as to what is appropiate use. I’m not against a group using vote if they are doing it within the spirit of the system and when people realize what content the are doing. All of your reasons are perfectly fine in extreme or savage groups especially if they are party finder groups. Also, party premades for dungeons use whatever rules you want. In those groups you set the rules. In Duty finder you sign up for random players and random content.

Edit. Keep in mind i’m Not talking about players than can’t meet dps checks in base dungeons, or tanks that pull slowly in harnessing manners.