White Raven earring given out at The Rising event 2018

[Zsolen]

No, they wouldn't be able to because it was billed as a limited time event which they themselves said. So yes, if they said it was going to be limited and then change their mind later I can see how people would be annoyed.

You didn't answer the question I asked. Let's put feelings aside. Do you believe that if the Nael content from 1.x came out today and even was regulated to the classes and abilities of the time, that only the same 1.x characters would clear it?

[JamiaHaab]

You can go into ultimate right now and get the title and weapons but you can't with 1.0 because it's long dead and we aren't playing that game anymore. 5 year anniversary not the 8.

[Vaer]

You didn't answer the question I asked. Let's put feelings aside. Do you believe that if the Nael content from 1.x came out today and even was regulated to the classes and abilities of the time, that only the same 1.x characters would clear it?

Strawman. That has nothing to do with anything? They said it was a limited event which is my main issue with it. People are too focused on "they are just earrings" but are missing the point. They are giving out what are supposed to have been limited items.

If they remastered the fight, and didn't say during 1.x that it was a one time thing we wouldn't even be talking about this right now.

[Hestzhyen]

If the item text reads "REPLICA" then would that be okay?

The design is cool and I've wanted it ever since I joined in 2.1. But I wouldn't want to take away the achievement for those who earned it... it would be like making the exact UwU weapons available from the Achievement Point vendor five years from now. Yeah there probably aren't enough people left from that time to worry about the PR/sub loss by angering them, but shouldn't you try to do right by your most dedicated fans when you have the opportunity?

[Kallera]

You can go into ultimate right now and get the title and weapons but you can't with 1.0 because it's long dead and we aren't playing that game anymore. 5 year anniversary not the 8.

Let’s not kid ourselves, this is going to be in an easily beatable fate, and even if it isn’t (unlikely), they didn’t take any consideration that some of those people with their names in the credits might be still playing?

I mean, really?

[Aviars]

If the item text reads "REPLICA" then would that be okay?

Nope. We don't accept loopholes here.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

Nope. We don't accept loopholes here.

Actually, a replica would be fine imo. its the item itself thats the problem. Same with the goobbue mount. The one you were able to get in 1.0 is different than the current one, so its not a problem.

I also didnt have a problem with the crafted relic skins, as the look slightly different.

The issue here isn't that an item from 1.0 is available, its that the item for beating basically the ultimate mode of the final boss of 1.0 is being given away for an easy event.

Item name and item text are not the same things.

I mean in the sense that if they made a replica of the white ravens, were called "Replica White Ravens", and had a slightly different color scheme, it would be fine.

[Kallera]

Actually, replica would be fine imo. its the item itself thats the problem. Same with the goobbue mount. The one you were able to get in 1.0 is different than the current on.

I also didnt have a problem with the crafted relic skins, as the look slightly different.

Item name and item text are not the same things.

[Bloodkraft]

I am a legacy player and also a beta tester for 14; and iI think it's a good thing that they make some of the old items available now - Share the love.

[Doki]

Dalmud Horn & OG Gobbue mount on Mogstation soon!
Legacy Chocobo & Legacy Tattoo can't be far behind!
When everyone is super, no one is.