New Crafting Class

[kikix12]

And you're misunderstanding both of us when you keep calling it "Shepherd".

You brought up a class that gathers monster materials. Aka what is not available for other disciples of land. I used the word Shepherd cause it's simply clear what that involves.

In fact, you're confusing ElHeggunte's DoL job that he specifically called "Salvager"(...)

I'm not. I didn't say anything at all about ElHeggunte's salvager idea. Not directly nor indirectly.

(...)you go out and find stuff, just like any MIN or BTN, and even though I had been using the name of "Scavenger" for it elsewhere, it still follows the exact same principle.

Read my post. I specifically said that there are two ways it could work. Either the whole "sim" mini-game, or gathering from wild monsters/random gather spots (from invisible carcasses etc.). The second part would make the class "broken" in that it would be far too efficient in comparison to disciple of war or magic.

I won't repeat myself fully. I don't have the time for that. Just read my previous post again, carefully this time.

[Kazrah]

You brought up a class that gathers monster materials.

How do you know that the ONLY way you could ever possibly get them is directly from the monster and by absolutely no other possible way? People leave things behind, whether it be in trash pits or cubbyholes. Every creature leaves things behind or else we'd know nothing of the past. That's what I meant when I'm saying that a gathering class that could find leftover things like leather scraps or other bits that could've been from monsters or elsewhere.

As for the "too efficient" argument, you must be one of those people who get their in-game lumber exclusively from killing bilokos or other tree mobs and their gems and ores just by killing golems.