Please let us buy gil since it's not pay to win.

[Rokke]

Not that confusing... I'm not arguing that buying gil is p2w... it's economy destroying... you might as well remove gil from the game... you flood a server with gil and the value of gil drops...which makes MB prices rise... which pushes more people to buy gil...
The cycle continues... you end up with people then RMT MB items because it ends up being cheaper than buying the gil to buy the item that way... I've seen it happen elsewhere... people demanding in game currency 10x and more beyond the players max currency cap for a single item... vs giving the seller 100 USD and just getting the item... SE won't even see it coming

Why bend over backwards to defend the app across multiple threads and draw the line here? Both have the potential to wreck the economy. Your arguments for the app say its ok because mb =/= winning the game. So whats your problem with selling gil? Why were you fine with the app wrecking the mb but why not this?

Quite frankly, I don’t want either implemented, but everyones flip flopping across the previous 17 pages boils down to “this one is ok because it won’t effect me significantly …b-but this one is bad dirty wrong (because it will effect me!!!)”. They're either both bad and you should hate both of them or they're both ok and you should be ok with both of them.