Yeah, none of these situations allow the introduction of 'new' gil into the system. But still, even if you wanted to be anti-new gil. Why not lamblast the fact that every character boost is automatically given 600,000 gil worth of allagan platinum pieces? My biggest beef with the FFXIV community is the sheer bias and acceptance of some skeptical issues, but the outright disapproval of others.

We got people say some things are ok, and other things are not, but without any defined logic. And without a solid understanding of what should be right and what should be wrong--square enix will constantly push the envelope. And that's worrysome