Revisiting the physick question

[silverlunarfox]

Because now summoning the fearie doesn't take up too much time or mp dissipation is much more useful, in fact I've seen it beign used on ultimate, let' say now it's an help when you need that extra healing and shield power and/or extra stacks.

but it remains that dissapation is still a niche ability. as a scholar I rarely need to use it.

~

The classes don't need to be split anymore, they did a good job mostly separating the two while keeping a few common acn abilities. As for physick, it should be removed and replaced with something both classes would find useful. I'm not sure what that could be, but you could have some fun making a new arcanist ability either class could use.

[Remedi]

but it remains that dissapation is still a niche ability. as a scholar I rarely need to use it.

~

The classes don't need to be split anymore, they did a good job mostly separating the two while keeping a few common acn abilities. As for physick, it should be removed and replaced with something both classes would find useful. I'm not sure what that could be, but you could have some fun making a new arcanist ability either class could use.

I Haven't said that is a must use ability I did said it was idd niche, however now it doesn't really screws you over and is actually usable.

That said I can't really consider them having done a good job at separating the job when we are having this discussion because SMN has a leftover spell that was ONLY added to it because SCH had to have acces to a cure (and a raise).
If you think that they should cover up this dead concept with upgrading trait then by all means, still I believe that since the system is no more they should just remove it and not keep it as a corpse.
UNLESS that is they want to try it again eventually in the future